Twenty-seven years ago today, on September 7, 1999, Sam Mendes’ American Beauty premiered in Los Angeles, introducing audiences to one of the most unsettling portraits of American suburban life of its era.
Written by Alan Ball and led by Kevin Spacey, Annette Bening and Thora Birch, the film turned the apparently comfortable world of manicured lawns, immaculate houses, and family dinners into a darkly comic study of dissatisfaction, desire, and emotional decay.
Its impact was immediate. By March 2000, American Beauty had collected five Academy Awards, winning Best Picture, Best Director for Mendes, Best Actor for Spacey, Best Original Screenplay for Ball, and Best Cinematography for Conrad L. Hall.
An Oscar Winner That Entered the Canon
The more interesting part of American Beauty’s legacy, however, is how firmly it entered popular conceptions of the greatest films of its generation. Empire’s all-time polling provides unusually clear evidence.
In the magazine’s 2003 ranking of the 100 greatest movies of all time, American Beauty landed at No. 31, ahead of films including Aliens, Back to the Future, and Apocalypse Now. It performed even better in Empire’s 2007 poll, reaching No. 11, placing it among films such as The Matrix, Goodfellas and The Empire Strikes Back.
Indeed, American Beauty did rank above both The Matrix and Goodfellas in specific Empire polls conducted over the years.
Poll | American Beauty Rank | Goodfellas Rank | The Matrix Rank |
Empire (2001 Poll) | 14 | 8 | 5 |
Empire Australian Edition (2007 Poll) | 12 | 10 | 11 |
Empire (2014 Poll) | 30 | 13 | 23 |
The table above show how American Beauty performed better relative to these two films in earlier polls. It did rank lower than both The Matrix and Goodfellas in the 2001 poll, but by the 2007 Australian poll, it had climbed to #12, placing it just behind Goodfellas (#10) but ahead of The Matrix (#11). Then in later years, such as the 2014 poll, both Goodfellas and The Matrix were ranked significantly higher.
Time Has Complicated Its Reputation
Its standing has since become more complicated. While Empire’s 2017 readers’ poll placed American Beauty at No. 60 (a substantial fall from its earlier positions), sharing the 100-film canon with The Godfather, Citizen Kane, Psycho, Vertigo, and Seven Samurai is no small feat after nearly two decades.
In fact, the fall to no.60 says something important about the film’s place in cinema.
American Beauty may no longer command the near-universal reverence that greeted it around the turn of the millennium, yet its presence across multiple all-time polls demonstrates remarkable staying power. Its sharp performances, stylized cinematography and brutally observant examination of suburban emptiness made it far more than an Oscar winner.
For a film released in 1999, its journey through successive “greatest” lists remains an unusually revealing measure of how cultural reputations evolve.
from Men's Journal https://ift.tt/L6kYSEn




